Vitamin & Mineral Supplements:
We are often asked about vitamins and fluoride.
Vitamins & minerals are non-nutritive (i.e. they do not provide
"fuel" or energy for the body) substances found in food which are
essential (in small amounts) for certain biological processes to occur. Most
well nourished children
in the United States get plenty of vitamins naturally in their diet. Vitamins
do not treat the common cold, nor do they affect allergies, immunity, or hyperactivity.
A child who is malnourished or growing poorly may benefit from vitamin
supplements in terms of preventing the metabolic consequences of a deficiency,
but vitamins by themselves will not help them grow.
Vitamin deficiencies are quite uncommon nowadays, and will usually show up early on the
periodic routine blood tests we do. Indeed, the advent of recommendations
for such routine bloodwork in the early 1980's brought with it an era (which
lasted 20 years) in which it was felt there was no need for routine vitamin
supplements at all in healthy, well nourished children or adolescent boys.
During that era, only menstruating adolescent (and adult) females were thought
to need routine supplements (mainly for iron and, in more recent years,
calcium). Recently, however, a number of discoveries have started to call
into question this wisdom . The first was the increasing awareness that
osteoporosis in the elderly has it's roots in childhood - that calcium stores
built up in childhood last a lifetime, and that it's hard to catch-up on your
calcium stores once you are an adult. The second has been the increasing
awareness of the importance of a number of trace elements (e.g. Zinc) which
heretofore were not on our "radar screen". Third, we now know
that a number of vitamins with anti-oxidant properties can prevent
atherosclerosis (the main cause of heart attacks & stroke later in
life), and that this too has it's roots in childhood. Fourth, the recent
discovery that Folate
can prevent Spina Bifida has led to calls for all women to take supplements
from an early age (so that getting extra Folate is automatic, not something you
need to do special in preparation for pregnancy). Finally, while we have
always known that Vitamin D is crucial for calcium absorption, until recently we
thought that sunlight and fortification of milk would be enough to ensure
everybody had enough (the skin manufactures Vitamin D when exposed to
sun). Recent data suggests this may not always be true, and it's hard to
predict which specific children aren't getting enough sunlight or milk from
history alone.
All of the above has led to a change in our recommendations regarding
Vitamins. We now
recommend that ALL CHILDREN receive a supplemental multivitamin daily.
This should start
at 2 weeks age for breastfed babies, and at time of weaning from formula to
regular milk in bottle-fed babies (a baby who receives both breast and bottle
can be considered bottle-fed for these purposes if they get more than 500cc, or
16oz, of formula per day). Supplementation should continue through adolescence. Any of the many
standard brands (Poly-vi-sol, Centrum, One-a-Day, Flintstones, many others...)
available over the counter without a prescription are fine, as long as you
follow the package guidelines for age-appropriateness & dosing.
Usually this will be drops for infants & toddlers, and chewable tablets for
preschoolers and school age children. When children reach the middle
school years, they may begin taking adult multivitamin tablets. All of these products will provide adequate amounts of
all the necessary vitamins and minerals (except Fluoride)
for all children except girls
>9y. Girls
in the teen and pre-teen years need more Calcium than the standard
multivitamin will provide. We
recommend that in addition to a multivitamin, they also take a separate Calcium
Supplement (Citracal, Caltrate, many others...)
in a dose of 800mg daily.
Finally, a word about combined Fluoride-multivitamin products (Tri-vi-flor,
Poly-vi-flor). We do not recommend or prescribe these for two
reasons. First, they contain a less complete vitamin and mineral set than
most of the OTC multivitamins. Second, Fluoride is best given alone, at
bedtime, separate from the multivitamin (which should be given with a meal
earlier in the day). Therefore we prefer prescribing Fluoride as a
separate medication. |